编号 lyqk006757

中文标题 非法采伐及相关贸易研究综述

作者 缪东玲 

作者单位 北京林业大学经济管理学院,北京 100083

期刊名称 世界林业研究 

年份 2018 

卷号 31

期号 3

栏目编号 1

栏目名称 专题论述 

中文摘要 文中在回顾非法采伐及相关贸易问题演变过程的基础上，综述主要研究方向及其进展，总结研究的主要方法和结论。非法采伐及其相关贸易问题本身具有多面性、多维度的特点，且其范围逐渐扩展。现有研究多停留于宏观层面，涉及非法采伐的定义和维度，涵盖非法采伐及相关贸易的规模、驱动因素、影响、治理形式和效果等，但缺少微观企业层面的理论和实证研究。GFPM、EFI-GTM等模型和半结构访谈方法被广泛应用于影响、治理的相关实证研究。

关键词 非法采伐  木材贸易  非法森林活动  研究动态  研究方法  文献综述 

基金项目 北京林业大学青年教师科学研究中长期项目（2015ZCQ-JG-02）；北京林业大学重大科研成果培育项目（20170316）。

英文标题 Literature Review of Illegal Logging and Associated Trade

作者英文名 Miao Dongling

单位英文名 School of Economics and Management, Beijing Forestry University, Beijing 100083, China

英文摘要 The paper reviewed the directions and progress of the research on illegal logging and associated trade, and concluded the major research approaches and conclusions based on the reviews of the evolving process of this issue. Illegal logging and associated trade is an issue with multi-faceted and multi-dimensional characteristics, and its scope has been gradually expanding. There are more studies on the macro level than on micro level, which involve the definition and dimensions of illegal logging, with the coverage on its scale, driving factors, impacts, governance and effects, while few studies have been made on the theory and empirical research at enterprise level. The methods such as GFPM, EFI-GTM and semi-structured interview are widely used in the empirical research on its influence and governance.

英文关键词 illegal logging;illegal forest activities;research progress;research approach;literature review

起始页码 1

截止页码 8

投稿时间 2017/11/14

最后修改时间 2018/3/23

作者简介 缪东玲(1971-),女,云南曲靖人,北京林业大学经济管理学院国际贸易系副教授,博士,主要研究方向:林产品市场与贸易、贸易与环境、国际贸易政策与实务,E-mail:donglingm@bjfu.edu.cn。

分类号 F746;F316.20;X24

DOI 10.13348/j.cnki.sjlyyj.2018.0031.y

参考文献 [1] HUMPHREYS D.Logjam:deforestation and the crisis of global governance[R].London:Earthscan,2006.
[2] LEIPOLD S,SOTIROV M,FREI T,et al.Protecting First World markets and Third World nature:the politics of illegal logging in Australia, the European Union and the United States[J].Global Environmental Change,2016,39:294-304.
[3] HOARE A.Tackling illegal logging and the related trade:what progress and where next?[R].London:Chatham House,2015.
[4] HOBLEY M,BUCHY M.FLEGT and poverty alleviation:the role of VPAs[R].Joenssu,Finland:European Forestry Institute,2011.
[5] KLEINSCHMIT D,MANSOURIAN S,WILDBURGER C,et al.Illegal logging and related timber trade:dimensions, drivers, impacts and responses:a global scientific rapid response assessment report[R].Vienna,Austria:IUFRO,2016.
[6] CONTRERAS-HERMOSILLA A.Illegal forest production and trade:an overview[R].Washington DC:The World Bank,2002.
[7] TACCONI L,BOSCOLO M,BRACK D.National and international policies to control illegal forest activities[R].Bogor,Indonesia:Centre for International Forestry Research,2003.
[8] BRACK D.Illegal logging and the illegal trade in forest and timber products[J].International Forestry Review,2003,5(3):195-198.
[9] KAIMOWITZ D.Forest law enforcement and rural livelihoods[J].International Forestry Review,2003,5(3):199-210.
[10] OCHIENG R M,VISSEREN-HAMAKERS I J,NKETIAH K S.Interaction between the FLEGTVPA and REDD+ in Ghana:recommendations for interaction management[J].Forest Policy and Economics,2013,32:32-39.
[11] HANSEN C P,TREUE T.Assessing illegal logging in Ghana[J].International Forestry Review,2008,10(4):573-590.
[12] MARFO E.Chainsaw milling in Ghana:context, drivers and impacts[R].Wageningen,the Netherlands:Tropenbos International,2010.
[13] BLAY D,APPIAH M,DAMNYAG L,et al.Involving local farmers in the rehabilitation of degraded tropical forests:some lessons from Ghana[J].Environment Development and Sustainability,2007,10(4):503-518.
[14] OSEI-TUTU P,NKETIAH K,KYEREH B,et al.Hidden forestry revealed:characteristics, constraints and opportunities for small and medium forest enterprises in Ghana[R].UK:Tropenbos International and International Institute for Environment and Development,2010.
[15] REBOREDO F.Socio-economic, environmental, and governance impacts of illegal logging[J].Environment Systems and Decisions,2013,33(2):295-304.
[16] RICHARDZ M,WELLS A,Del GATTO F,et al.Impacts of illegality and barriers to legality:a diagnostic analysis of illegal logging in Honduras and Nicaragua[J].International Forestry Review,2003,5(3):282-292.
[17] MUKUL S A,HERBOHN J,RASHID A Z,et al.Comparing the effectiveness of forest law enforcement and economic incentives to prevent illegal logging in Bangladesh[J].International Forestry Review,2014,16(3):363-375.
[18] BOURIAUD L,NICHIFOREL L,NUNES L,et al.A property rights-based analysis of the illegal logging for fuelwood in Kosovo[J].Biomass and Bioenergy,2014,67:425-434.
[19] AMACHER G S,KOSKELA E,OLLIKAINEN M.Royalty reform and illegal reporting of harvest volumes under alternative penalty schemes[J].Environmental and Resource Economics,2007,38(2):189-211.
[20] AMACHER G S.Corruption:a challenge for economists interested in forest policy design[J].Journal of Forest Economics,2006,12(2):85-89.
[21] AMACHER G S,OLLIKAINEN M,KOSKELA E.Corruption and forest concessions[J].Journal of Environmental Economics and Management,2012,63(1):92-104.
[22] FRANCK M,HANSEN C P.How effective are task forces in tackling illegal logging?:empirical evidence from Ghana[J].International Forestry Review,2014,16(3):354-362.
[23] SUNDSTRÖM A.Understanding illegality and corruption in forest governance[J].Journal of Environmental Management,2016,181:779-790.
[24] MEEHAN F,TACCONI L.A framework to assess the impacts of corruption on forests and prioritize responses[J].Land Use Policy,2017,60:113-122.
[25] LESCUYER G,CERUTTI P O,TSANGA R.Contributions of community and individual small-scale logging to sustainable timber management in Cameroon[J].International Forestry Review,2016,18(1):40-51.
[26] FOUNDJEM-TITA D,SPEELAM S,TIEGUHONG J C,et al.A choice experiment approach for assessing preferences to forest law configuration and compliance:the case of NTFP traders in Cameroon[J].International Forestry Review,2013,15(2):241-254.
[27] COSSÍO R E,PERZ S,KAINER K.Capacity for timber management in small and medium forest enterprises:a case study from the Peruvian Amazon[J].Small-scale Forestry,2011,10(4):489-507.
[28] KHAI T C,MIZOUE N,KAJISA T,et al.Stand structure, composition and illegal logging in selectively logged production forests of Myanmar:comparison of two compartments subject to different cutting frequency[J].Global Ecology and Conservation,2016,7:132-140.
[29] LOWE A J,DORMONTT E E,BOWIE M J,et al.Opportunities for improved transparency in the timber trade through scientific verification[J].BioScience,2016,66(11):990-998.
[30] DORMONTT E E,BONER M,BRAUN B,et al.Forensic timber identification:it's time to integrate disciplines to combat illegal logging[J].Biological Conservation,2015,191:790-798.
[31] HASSOLD S,LOWRY Ⅱ P P,BAUERT M R,et al.DNA barcoding of malagasy rosewoods:towards a molecular identification of CITES-listed dalbergia species[J].PloS One,2016,11(6):e0157881.
[32] CHARWAT-PESSLER J,SCHRAML R,ENTACHER K,et al.Tracking logs with RGB images within the wood supply chain:a preliminary study on image acquisition[J].Forest Products Journal,2016,66(3/4):176-184.
[33] MARFO E.Chainsaw milling in Ghana:context, drivers and impacts[R].Wageningen,the Netherlands:Tropenbos International,2010.
[34] BOAKYE J.Estimation of illegal logging by the formal timber sector in Ghana:implications for forest law compliance, enforcement and EU-Ghana voluntary partnership agreement[J].International Forestry Review,2015,17(2):117-127.
[35] AMOAH M,BOATENG R K.Addressing illegal logging in Ghana:do value, social identity, and corporate social responsibility theories matter?[J].International Forestry Review,2014,16(6):524-536.
[36] LESCUYER G,MVONGO-NKENE M N,MONVILLE G,et al.Promoting multiple-use forest management:which trade-offs in the timber concessions of Central Africa?[J].Forest Ecology and Management,2015,349:20-28.
[37] AKINDUTIRE A F.Criminality:illegal logging of woods in Nigeria's south-west forest belt[J].African Journal of Criminology and Justice Studies,2016,9(1):141-153.
[38] WERTZ-KANOUNNIKOFF S,FALCÃO M P,PUTZEL L.Facing China's demand for timber:an analysis of Mozambique's forest concession system with insights from Cabo Delgado Province[J].International Forestry Review,2013,15(3):387-397.
[39] SALAHODJAEV R.Intelligence and deforestation:international data[J].Forest Policy and Economics,2016,63:20-27.
[40] 缪东玲.打击木材非法采伐及其相关贸易的全球治理分析[J].国际经贸探索,2011,27(9):72-77.
[41] 管志杰,曹建华.非法采伐及其贸易的治理:生态供应链的视角[J].北京林业大学学报(社会科学版),2014,13(2):75-80.
[42] 陈积敏,钱静,贺祥瑞.打击木材非法采伐与贸易的执法困境探析[J].林业经济,2014(7):68-71.
[43] GUAN Z,GONG P.The impacts of international efforts to reduce illegal logging on China's forest products trade flow[J].China Agricultural Economic Review,2015,7(3):467-483.
[44] 缪东玲,程宝栋.打击木材非法采伐及其相关贸易的立法现状和影响研究[J].林业经济评论,2014(4):19-28.
[45] LEIPOLD S.How to move companies to source responsibly?:German implementation of the European Timber Regulation between persuasion and coercion[J].Forest Policy and Economics,2017,84:41-51.
[46] PRESTEMON J P.The impacts of the Lacey Act Amendment of 2008 on U.S. hardwood lumber and hardwood plywood imports[J].Forest Policy and Economics,2015,50:31-44.
[47] LU Z,GANGULY I,EASTIN I.A categorical modeling approach to analyzing the impacts of the Lacey Act 2008 amendment on Chinese companies' export cost and the implications on their sourcing behaviors[J].Canadian Journal of Forest Research,2015,45(12):1806-1815.
[48] GORDON S M.The Foreign Corrupt Practices Act:prosecute corruption and end transnational illegal logging[J].The Boston College Environmental Affairs Law Review,2016,43(1):111-144.
[49] MARYUDI A.Choosing timber legality verification as a policy instrument to combat illegal logging in Indonesia[J].Forest Policy and Economics,2016,68:99-104.
[50] SETYOWATI A,McDERMOTT C L.Commodifying legality?:who and what counts as legal in the Indonesian wood trade[J].Society & Natural Resources,2016,17:1-15.
[51] LUTTRELL C,OBIDZINSKI K,BROCKHAUS M,et al.Lessons for REDD+ from measures to control illegal logging in Indonesia:CIFOR working paper 74[R].Bogor,Indonesia:CIFOR,2011.
[52] FISHMAN A,OBIDZINSKI K.Verified Legal?:ramifications of the EU Timber Regulation and Indonesia's Voluntary Partnership Agreement for the legality of Indonesian timber[J].International Forestry Review,2015,17(1):10-19.
[53] OVERDEVEST C,ZEITLIN J.Constructing a transnational timber legality assurance regime:architecture, accomplishments, challenges[J].Forest Policy and Economics,2014,48:6-15.
[54] CASHORE B,STONE M.Can legality verification promote good forest governance?:lessons from Indonesia, Malaysia, and Brazil[C].The International Studies Association Annual Meeting,San Francisco,USA,April 2013.
[55] OVERDEVEST C,ZEITLIN J.Experimentalism in transnational forest governance:implementing EU Forest Law Enforcement Governance and Trade (FLEGT) Voluntary Partnership Agreements in Indonesia and Ghana[EB/OL].(2016-06-15)[2017-10-10].http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2802659.
[56] GAVRILUT I,HALALISAN A F,GIURCA A,et al.The interaction between FSC certification and the implementation of the EU Timber Regulation in Romania[J].Forests,2016,7(1).DOI:10.3390/f7010003.
[57] TRISHKIN M,LOPATIN E,KARJALAINEN T.Exploratory assessment of a company's due diligence system against the EU Timber Regulation:a case study from northwestern Russia[J].Forests,2015,6(4):1380-1396.
[58] 缪东玲,田禾,程宝栋.木材合法性认证及其对中国木质林产品贸易的影响[J].世界林业研究,2014,27(2):61-65.
[59] LI R,BUONGIORNO J,TURNER J A,et al.Long-term effects of eliminating illegal logging on the world forest industry, trade and inventory[J].Forest Policy and Economics,2008,10(7/8):480-490.
[60] HANSEN C P,DAMNYAG L,OBIRI B D,et al.Revisiting illegal logging and the size of the domestic timber market:the case of Ghana[J].International Forestry Review,2012,14(1):39-49.
[61] BRUNNER J,TALBOTT K,ELKIN C.Logging Burma's frontier forests:resources and the regime[R].Washington DC:World Resources Institute,1998.
[62] JOHNSON S.Documenting the undocumented[J].ITTO Tropical Forest Update,2002(12):6-9.
[63] CASTAÑO J.Sustainable timber trade:are discrepancies in trade data reliable indicators of illegal activities?[C].IV International Conference on Agricultural Statistics:Advancing Statistical Integration and Analysis,Beijing,China,2007.
[64] CHANG Y,PENG R.Timber flow study:export/import discrepancy analysis:China vs. Mozambique, Cameroon, Uganda and DRC[R].London:International Institute for Environment and Development,2015.
[65] LAWSON S.Illegal logging and related trade:measuring the global response[R].London:Chatham House,2007.
[66] DIETER M.Analysis of trade in illegally harvested timber:accounting for trade via third party countries[J].Forest Policy and Economics,2009,11(8):600-607.
[67] JOHNSON S.Estimating the extent of illegal trade of tropical forest products[J].International Forestry Review,2003,5(3):247-252.
[68] LAWSON S,MACFAUL L.Illegal logging and related trade:indicators of the global response[R].London:Chatham House,2010.
[69] PRASETYO A,HEWITT J,KEONG CH.Scoping baseline information for forest law enforcement, governance and trade[R].Kuala Lumpur,Malaysia:FLEGT Facility Asia Regional Office,2012.
[70] KNAUF M.An analysis of wood market balance modeling in Germany[J].Forest Policy and Economics,2015,50:319-326.
[71] CONTRERAS-HERMOSILLA A,DOORNBOSCH R,LODGE M.The economics of illegal logging and associated trade[R].Paris:Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development,2007.
[72] LAWSON S.Methodology for import-source estimates of illegally sourced wood imports:Thailand, South Korea and India[R].London:Chatham House,2014.
[73] LAWSON S.Consumer goods and deforestation:an analysis of the extent and nature of illegality in forest conversion for agriculture and timber plantations[R].Washington DC,USA:Forest Trends,2014.
[74] ZHANG X,XU B,WANG L,et al.Eliminating illegal timber consumption or production:which is the more economical means to reduce illegal logging?[J].Forests,2016,7(9).DOI:10.3390/f7090191.
[75] MOISEYEV A,SOLBERG B,MICHIE B,et al.Modeling the impacts of policy measures to prevent import of illegal wood and wood products[J].Forest Policy and Economics,2010,12(1):24-30.
[76] BOSELLO F,PARRADO R,ROSA R.The economic and environmental effects of an EU ban on illegal logging imports:insights from a CGE assessment[J].Environment and Development Economics,2013,18(2):184-206.
[77] TURNER J,KATZ A,BUONGIORNO J.Implications for the New Zealand wood products sector of trade distortions due to illegal logging[R].Wellington,New Zealand:Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry,2007.
[78] LEIPOLD S,WINKEL G.Divide and conquer-discursive agency in the politics of illegal logging in the United States[J].Global Environmental Change,2016,36:35-45.
[79] GAN J,CERUTTI P O,MASIERO M,et al.Quantifying illegal logging and related timber trade[R]//KLEINSCHMIT D,MANSOURIAN S,WILDBURGER C,et al(eds).Illegal logging and related timber trade:dimensions, drivers, impacts and responses:a global scientific rapid response assessment report.Vienna,Austria:IUFRO,2016:37-60.

PDF全文 浏览全文